The Efficiency That Ruins Results | Episode 471

  Listen on SpotifyListen on Apple Podcasts Curious if Octalysis fits your engagement challenge? Quick intro chat: professorgame.com/strategy

Episode Summary

Rob examines the efficiency vs motivation trade-off in product design, showing why a plan that runs at 110% leaves no room to recover from a bad day or a bad week. He covers Yu-kai Chou’s function-focused versus human-focused design, Bernard Suits’ definition of a game as the voluntary attempt to overcome unnecessary obstacles, and the test for a friction bottleneck versus a motivation bottleneck, drawing on Disney queues, golf, and a bed that turned his daughter’s birthday into a five-hour assembly job. Listeners learn to ask what a buffer or an efficiency loss is paying for before cutting it, and how to tell a tax imposed on people from an obstacle they choose.

About the Host

Rob Alvarez is Head of Engagement Strategy, Europe at The Octalysis Group (TOG), a leading gamification and behavioral design consultancy. A globally recognized gamification strategist and TEDx speaker, he founded and hosts Professor Game, the #1 gamification podcast, and has interviewed hundreds of global experts. He designs evidence-based engagement systems that drive motivation, loyalty, and results, and teaches LEGO® SERIOUS PLAY® and gamification at top institutions including IE Business School, EFMD, and EBS University across Europe, the Americas, and Asia.

Key Takeaways

  • Bernard Suits defined playing a game as the voluntary attempt to overcome unnecessary obstacles, which is why golf can forbid the most efficient route and still work: the obstacle is chosen, so it feels like play.
  • Yu-kai Chou’s function-focused design assumes people will do their part because the task requires it, like factory workers, while human-focused design starts from the motivation of the person behind the task.
  • Every gamification layer adds efficiency loss, and that loss only pays off when it buys motivational gain; efficiency loss with no motivational gain is where bad gamification happens.
  • Before optimizing, find out whether the bottleneck is friction or motivation: in BJ Fogg’s model, lowering friction helps only when people already have some motivation and the right trigger.
  • Slack is time set aside for something you cannot yet name, and a plan that asks for 110% of what people can give has no way to absorb a bad day, let alone a bad week.
  • Waits that nobody designed, like a long Disney queue, feel like a tax because of what they cost: the time you cannot spend working, with family, or with friends.

Topics Covered

Mentioned in This Episode

Free Resources and Get in Touch

Looking forward to reading or hearing from you, Rob Full episode transcription (AI Generated)

A bed arrives without its installation

Rob Alvarez (00:00:00): It was her birthday, and I’d blocked the whole day. Then her bed arrived while she was at school. And the installation that was supposed to come with the bed apparently fell out of the purchase. As you might tell, many plans and programs run at 110%. Every single piece of the way is spoken for. There’s no room to recover after a missed day or let alone a week. So I’m Rob, I’m the head of Engagement Strategy Europe at the Octalysis Group, the leading gamification and behavioral design consultancy group, and also the host of Professor Game, the number one gamification and behavioral design podcast in the space. Rob Alvarez (00:00:39): So, as I was saying before, I had blocked that Thursday, which was when her birthday happened, without knowing what I was blocking it for, my agenda, my calendar, you could see that no people could set up meetings or anything. The bed. That I mentioned before took three, four, maybe five hours of that. So on this episode, I’m gonna leave you with something that you can take immediately today if you’re listening to this on Monday back to your product. Rob Alvarez (00:01:08): What is the plan? We’re gonna have talk about a story. We’re gonna talk, of course, about games and a question. Games, not in the general sense, games in the sense of how this can apply to your product. So

Clearing the day for an unknown surprise

Rob Alvarez (00:01:20): What I had set aside for, I I didn’t really know what it was. It’s it’s a birthday. in our house, birthdays usually come with some sort of surprise, pleasant or sometimes unpleasant. So I pretty much cleared the day. This bed that we had purchased, we didn’t really know when it was arriving. It was not IKEA. IKEA usually gives you a day when it arrives. The space, as you might or might not know here in Madrid, spaces tend to be very tight, so the bed literally just fits on that place. Rob Alvarez (00:01:50): So putting it together is not an easy task, especially as after I just told you. It’s not IKEA. IKEA, I’m already used to knowing how it goes, and I know that everything is gonna turn out alright if I just follow the instructions. So it took three, four, probably five hours, and not only hours, I was also On the floor, and I ended up with very, very sore hands. How did I push through that that that physical side of it? Rob Alvarez (00:02:16): My gym habit, which has been around for a bit and it’s helping me with my back, which has been a big struggle for a significant part of my life. And you know, apparently there’s this thing called deep squats, which I’ve read and seen that they’re apparently very good for your hips and lower back. And I’ve been doing that. But that allowed me to stay low pretty close to the floor without sitting, which is something that is very, very unpleasant for my back, flat on the floor. Rob Alvarez (00:02:41): I was able to manage to do all that kind of workout during all that time because I was quote unquote prepared for it. These are things that you kind of prepare yourself for, not knowing exactly what you will need it. I mean, some people go to the gym just to look fantastic, which is great. I I respect that. I that’s not my thing. I I like to look good, of course. But my main thing is being, you know, prepared, being strong, because life brings these kinds of surprises and other things. I like to carry my daughter and so on. Rob Alvarez (00:03:07): So those are things I’m getting prepared for.

Slack as time set aside for the unknown

Rob Alvarez (00:03:10): And in in terms of time, I didn’t, of course, know that the bed would be arriving. I literally didn’t know what would happen. I didn’t expect it would not be installed. So I set it apart because I almost knew that something would come up, because that’s kind of Murphy’s law as well, right? that slack is the time that you somehow set aside for something you are not. still very well aware of what it’s exactly going to be. Rob Alvarez (00:03:34): This case, of course, slack was relatively cheap. I was at home, I work from home. The fallback for me was relatively easy. I could just get back to regular work, get some stuff done. That was okay. Not using the slack was not a problem. In fact, it could give me time to do some work that I was, you know, I could just advance work, do some stuff that I haven’t done, whatever that could look like.

Why engineers treat slack as a bug

Rob Alvarez (00:03:53): as I graduated as a software engineer, we are, amongst other things, we’re trained to treat that slack as a bug or something to fill. We’re efficiency driven. we’re in a way we’re kind of lazy. We do, you know, let’s say a task it needs to be done many, many times. That’s usually repetitive tasks. That’s what in the past, at least now with AI, it might be changing quite a bit. But one of the things that we did is, you know, you do it need to do something and it needs to be repeated a thousand, a million times. Rob Alvarez (00:04:18): So you do an effort, let’s say it’s a thousand, right? Do an effort of of twenty or even thirty or fifty, as if you were doing the task 50 times. But instead of doing that, you prepare a system that is going to be able to do the task the thousand times without you being involved. So you actually save, you know, what was it, a thousand fifty? So 950 efforts is what you save. Rob Alvarez (00:04:38): We’re constantly looking for those efficiencies. How do I design a system so this doesn’t need to be taken care of by me? We’re efficiency driven.

Function-focused versus human-focused design

Rob Alvarez (00:04:47): And the thing is, even Yu-kai has a name for for this. He he’s he’s been talking about for a while, about this thing where you think you you get a job done, right? And and you assume people are gonna do their part. That’s what we call function focused design. There’s an example he uses of factory workers, they expect factory workers to do their jobs because they’re required to, right? they’re not thinking about their motivations. Rob Alvarez (00:05:12): Human focused design, on the other hand, starts from human motivation. You’re thinking about the person behind the task you’re setting up for them rather than assuming that they will do it because they have to, So what the factory assumes is that nobody also has a difficult day a Thursday, they’re assuming that they’re motivated and that nothing bad will happen. Everything needs to be efficiency, efficiency, efficiency driven.

What happens when a task needs 110%

Rob Alvarez (00:05:35): So what happens in your case, in your app? in your system, in your corporation, what happens when somebody is doing something and the task requires 110% of what they’re able to give? What happens when they have a bad day, when they have a bad week? So I mean, if if you’re making room for a bad week and you’re finding that that’s difficult, and of course it is, and and you want to do that without losing retention, without losing engagement in your system. Rob Alvarez (00:06:05): And that is something that you’re facing with your product. Just click the link in the description and we’ll have a very quick chat and look at what it can mean in your specific situation.

Forced inefficiency, from the bed to Disney queues

Rob Alvarez (00:06:15): So moving on. One of the things that that happens here is that you as we just discussed very recently in the past episode, this is kind of the way nobody designed for. It’s the I I didn’t I I was not expecting to spend all those hours setting up a bed because I we had in theory at least purchased the installation to come with a bed, literally that they came with all the package, came in, checked that everything is there, and actually leave when the bed was completely set up. Rob Alvarez (00:06:41): there were many things to get done and she had her. Birthday party at home as well. So we had many things to get ready. I have a lot of work to do all the time. So this was definitely not something I was looking forward to investing my time on. But it happened. I had the slack and nobody was coming to the rescue. So I built the bed myself. Inefficiency is when somebody imposes this on you. Rob Alvarez (00:07:02): That’s when it becomes a tax. What the Disney queues teach about teach product teams is that most waits customers feel like they these I mean of course if they’re not designed, you you feel like it’s a weight. You’re not expecting this. You don’t want it. The cost that you’re paying is that wait means you’re not able to do other things. It’s like when you go and do bureaucratic paperwork, right? You spend a lot of time just waiting for the person who’s gonna give you whatever piece of paper you’re looking for to be ready because they have a huge huge queue of other people there. Rob Alvarez (00:07:34): That is time you’re not working, you’re not spending whether you’re family, you’re not enjoying, you’re not out Friends, right? You’re not, it’s something you don’t want to do. That’s the real cost of a long line. You you can compare those those situations versus that’s an obstacle that they set up for you, or that just happens against your will.

Golf, Bernard Suits, and chosen obstacles

Rob Alvarez (00:07:53): Compare that to the game of golf. I don’t know if you’re a golfer listening to me, but think of golf, right? The the rules of golf obviously forbid you from the most efficient route. What is the most efficient route of achieving? Your results, you grab the ball, walk, or even get on the little cars, the electric cars that you have, go all the way to the hole and drop it inside the hole. Rob Alvarez (00:08:18): That’s you know, that’s a reference from Hurka, who was explaining Bernard Suits. And Suits literally says playing a game is the voluntary attempt to overcome those unnecessary obstacles. The rules say you cannot do this thing, but when you engage in this lusory attitude. You say, well, of course I’m not gonna grab the ball, I’m gonna use this stick, and I’m gonna make it really, really difficult. By the way, there’s a there’s a very funny if you look in YouTube, I think it’s how the the Irish invented golf, and there’s this guy making jokes about it. Rob Alvarez (00:08:46): It’s really, really funny because you see how it sounds ridiculous when you explain it that way, the rules of of the game, Voluntary here is is a word that is central. If You don’t accept that that’s the way the game’s gonna work. Everything is gonna be crazy and meaningless to you. You engage in that lusory attitude because you decide to do so. I want to play golf, and this is the way golf is played. Rob Alvarez (00:09:10): The same obstacle you place in front of the same person, two obstacles, one is forced upon them, the other one is chosen. They give you, let’s let’s call them very different results.

Before cutting waste, ask which waste

Rob Alvarez (00:09:20): So remember, when you’re about to to cut waits that we’ve talked about. How we can do design by deletion as well, which is really, really hard, by the way. Before you start cutting out things, you want to ask yourself, which waste was that? And who actually is there people who are coming for that thing that I’m considering waste? there there’s a I found an article recently. Of course, you know, Yu-kai a huge amount of things to to read, and and I go finding them here and there when I’m looking for references.

Friction bottleneck or motivation bottleneck

Rob Alvarez (00:09:48): He talks about this test, When you design using using gamification, behavioral design, what you’re essentially doing is you’re you’re paying with efficiency loss, I was saying at this some some some minutes ago, I was talking about how software engineers are efficiency driven. You do the most efficient thing. And lately, you know, UX has also been about how do you remove friction, remove friction, remove friction. When you introduce game elements, when you use gamification, when you do behavioral design, what you’re usually doing is you’re adding friction. Rob Alvarez (00:10:19): There’s an efficiency loss. It’s gonna be harder for the user to complete the task. But the question that you’re thinking here is do I have a bottleneck of friction, which is when you remove as much friction as you can because the user is somehow motivated, or do I have a motivation bottleneck? Are people not really motivated? Like you can do the most frictionless thing, but if nobody wants to do it, it doesn’t matter. People need to want to do it. Rob Alvarez (00:10:45): And you can’t force people by making it more efficient. Make it more efficient. if they have some motivation, lowering the friction in in Fogg’s model makes it such that they are there’s a better chance of them doing it. They have the right trigger and they already have some motivation. If they have no motivation, then you have to sacrifice some of that efficiency to make it more motivating, So efficiency loss really hurts when it doesn’t buy any motivational gain. Rob Alvarez (00:11:11): That’s where bad gamification happens. So what you’re asking when you introduce Behavioral design gamification is what are you paying for? What’s the efficiency? What’s the gain in motivation that you’re paying for with this efficiency loss? Is this something that a person would intentionally, voluntarily choose to do? is the person wanting to do that? What if it this whole system goes unused? Does the do people have a fallback? I don’t want all these, things you put, I just want to click through very quickly and want to do that. Rob Alvarez (00:11:39): Let’s say you have a very busy CTO, you don’t want them to have. necessarily all the system they just want to click through because they want to have an approval process and they they need to do it, they’re gonna do it anyway. So why create a motivational system behind that if they’re gonna do it anyway? That’s it’s it’s a waste of efficiency when you do that. And they might even get upset if it’s not done the right way.

What the Thursday buffer actually paid for

Rob Alvarez (00:11:57): So just like that efficiency loss is a price you’re paying for slack is also a price. It’s like when you when you in in operations, when I teach operations, I talked about this in last episode, you’re building if you build for the busiest hour of the busiest day You’re probably gonna go broke. Almost no operation is able to afford that. So the question is, what and how much slack and what is it paying for? Rob Alvarez (00:12:19): So before you cut all that waste, ask yourself, what is it paying for? That Thursday buffer for me is what absorbed the bed. When my daughter saw her new bed, she was over the moon. She she saw the bed where she would actually fit in. This is this is a free translation on my end, but I she said a couple of times before that, just like when you don’t fit into your clothes. Rob Alvarez (00:12:40): It’s it’s not my size anymore. she says something along those lines like, this bed is no longer my size. So, of course, when she saw a bed that was or is now her size, she was she was completely really, really happy that she would have a a real space where her her her arms would not just fall off the bed, So what is is is that thing that you were about to cut? What what is it? look at it? Rob Alvarez (00:13:03): do you need that slack for something? Are there unexpected things happening here and there that would be solved if you had a little bit of that slack? So if you want to explore that question in more depth with me, all you have to do is click on the link in the description and we’ll have a chat exactly about that. And Engagers, as you know at least for now and for today, it is time to say that it’s game over. End of transcription

Discover more from Professor Game

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.